Boost Your Planning by Combining SAP IBP and SAC Planning
SAP Analytics Cloud Planning supports mid- to long-term strategic planning, while SAP Integrated Business Planning focuses on more operational and immediate objectives. Why not combine the two within a global planning strategy?
SAP Analytics Cloud is often adopted alongside the intelligent ERP SAP S/4HANA, as it allows organizations to step back from the data and deliver strategic analyses, whereas the ERP is limited to operational analytics. However, SAP Analytics Cloud is not the only solution it can work with in tandem.
“In the planning domain, SAP Integrated Business Planning (SAP IBP) handles the industrial dimension, while SAP Analytics Cloud Planning (SAC Planning) covers the financial angle,” explains Frédéric Caillat, Supply Chain Practice Consultant at TeamWork. “One of the classic use cases is to feed a sales plan created in SAC Planning back into SAP IBP, in order to convert it into a production plan and assess its feasibility. This is a key element in ensuring that a company’s strategic plans are compatible with its actual production capacity.”
“SAP IBP is capable of taking financial aspects into account, but it generally stops at operating costs, whereas SAC Planning can go all the way up to net profit,” adds Camille Maitrot de la Motte, Data Analytics Team Leader at TeamWork. “SAP IBP is an operationally focused tool, while SAC Planning enables different departments to collaborate in building a single strategic vision. It can collect data from multiple systems to perform detailed projections that can, for example, extend as far as defining the P&L.”
Where should the line be drawn between the two solutions?
SAP IBP only evaluates production costs based on the strictly necessary resources required for execution (raw materials, labor, etc.), whereas SAC Planning can integrate additional elements such as marketing or sales costs. This makes it possible to assess key indicators like net margin with greater accuracy.
In the planning arena, SAC Planning and SAP IBP are complementary solutions. “SAC Planning is responsible for strategic planning (mid- to long-term), which is then translated into operational planning (shorter-term) in SAP IBP,” summarizes Camille Maitrot de la Motte. “In return, changes made to operational plans are fed back into SAC to verify their alignment with the company’s P&L.”
But where exactly does the boundary between the two offerings lie? “There is some overlap in functionality,” notes Frédéric Caillat. “This facilitates integration and provides flexibility in deciding where to draw the line between the two tools—between operational planning and strategic planning.” This is all the more important given that SAP IBP and SAC projects are rarely carried out simultaneously. As a result, their implementation scope is often not designed upfront for tandem operation—let alone in a triangular setup that also takes ERP interactions into account.
A fast project… if properly scoped upfront
From a technical standpoint, implementing an integration between SAP Integrated Business Planning and SAP Analytics Cloud Planning is a short project, as both solutions can communicate directly with each other and have clearly defined, complementary functional scopes. The main challenge lies in defining the data model: What do I want to analyze, and how often? Which data should be fed back from SAP IBP? What role will each stakeholder play in the process? Once the data model is defined and the objectives are set, the project can be delivered within relatively short timelines.
“The project scoping phase is essential,” confirms Camille Maitrot de la Motte. “TeamWork brings a methodology and best practices that help organizations clarify their needs while taking their specific context into account. We translate these needs into an appropriate data model and define interaction processes between the two solutions.”
During workshops, companies can leverage TeamWork’s experience gained from similar projects. This expertise enriches discussions and helps rethink the organization’s overall planning process.
